Macca's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

["The Fox and the Mirrior"]

[[[This is so fresh]]]

this was excellent. a new style to completly throw the portal off gaurd. I think that your drawing ability is amazing and would love to see how you do IN flash.

Overall i cant really fault this. i thought i was watching the behind the scenes rough drafts of a disney film. Brilliant, truly brilliant.

[There she is!! step 2]

[[[Excellent]]]

Simply ground breaking and one of the best things to grace the portal.

You sir are a credit to this site, and i look forward to any other submissions you make.

[Awx.I.TablesDevastation]

[[A poor tribute]]]

ok i understand you're a fan, but would it kill you to come up with your own characters. if you were to do a tribute you should ask yourself if you can do it justice, and you really didn't.

You seem to have a fair grasp of flash so try putting your own ideas together and come back at the portal with something new.

Flashmanbutnotgood

Live-s-Lifter responds:

im fully ok with you but i say to that its just a fast done submisoin not even finished n full of bugs ( the thing d'at all waste ).tell you wt i told wait for the real one

[MGS3: Boss Failures]

[[[Excellent idea]]

This was just what was needed in the portal.

Great idea and the bosses were great.

A part two would be nice to see maybe the same genre but for a diffrent game ?

It's in your hands but all in all well done.

My only complaint is the background. I know it had to be basic but maybe you could have found a way to liven it up. you could have also shown the director, however it worked fine without doing so.

all in all well done

Flashmanbutnotgood

[Elf Hunter]

[[[Seen Worse]]]

Could talk all day on this.

Think Background and colour.
Sound was ok

and the idea wasn't half bad.
Just spend more time on the presentation.

hthedinga responds:

Thanks, I'll definately incorporate more of those two things into the next animation. I had trouble with synching the sound, at one point the music lined up with what was going on, but it seems like it didn't work out in the final one.

[lightsaber boy ep. 1]

[[[Star was is the IN thing right now huh]]]

Ok, i have seen a lot worse mate but i suggest you stick to the far out shots since they make your graphics look a lot better.

Good idea and not bad in the main.

Flashmanbutnotgood

[The Coach Journey]

[[[Not bad]]]

Mmmmm ok i can see the plot and what you were trying to get here which is more than i can say for most newgrounds entries.

Clean up the graphics a little and you will go a long way.

Flashmanbutnotgood

[NAtickville Ep1 (pt 1)]

[[[A good effort]]]

This was ok it showed effort and your well on your way.

Improve the voice acting because it adds loads to the appearence.

Flashmanbutnotgood

Kalaloo-NB responds:

You're right. We'll work on that. Thank you.

[Retarded Animal Babies 13]

you have done it again Dave

you are one of the best things about this site and i would love to see you make the big time

all the best

flashmanbutnotgood

[Madness Depredation]

.

Thank you for making this. I really mean that. Thank you.