Macca's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[SSAM #3]

Great work Xander

Awesome work buddy, didn't even know you were working on this!

OurGuardian responds:

Hehe, I worked on this in a locked room telling nobody *evil grin*

[B&T Ep. 03 - Madly Lamb]

Twas ok.

The joke was good but this was reall short and their was very little movement.

Try making a bit of action or zoom ins and such to make it feel less static. also her hand could have moved. her left hand that is. it would be also if you could fret the same strings and make diffrent sounds lol.

good effort

Bob-The-Cheese responds:

yeah, it was kinda thrown together in a few hours, but such is the way of things. Alot of movement means alot of effort, and I really really hate fbfing things... I'll keep it in mind, though... cheers for the review...

[SSAM #1]

Excellent flash work

Xander you are an excellent flash artist and this movie kicked ass. I loved the music and the style was a ncie change. The story was simple yet touching

Well done!!

OurGuardian responds:

Thanks man, you rock too, thanks for helping me out.

[Awx.I.TablesDevastation]

[[A poor tribute]]]

ok i understand you're a fan, but would it kill you to come up with your own characters. if you were to do a tribute you should ask yourself if you can do it justice, and you really didn't.

You seem to have a fair grasp of flash so try putting your own ideas together and come back at the portal with something new.

Flashmanbutnotgood

Live-s-Lifter responds:

im fully ok with you but i say to that its just a fast done submisoin not even finished n full of bugs ( the thing d'at all waste ).tell you wt i told wait for the real one

[Elf Hunter]

[[[Seen Worse]]]

Could talk all day on this.

Think Background and colour.
Sound was ok

and the idea wasn't half bad.
Just spend more time on the presentation.

hthedinga responds:

Thanks, I'll definately incorporate more of those two things into the next animation. I had trouble with synching the sound, at one point the music lined up with what was going on, but it seems like it didn't work out in the final one.

[NAtickville Ep1 (pt 1)]

[[[A good effort]]]

This was ok it showed effort and your well on your way.

Improve the voice acting because it adds loads to the appearence.

Flashmanbutnotgood

Kalaloo-NB responds:

You're right. We'll work on that. Thank you.

[Magic Tricks (Stopmotion)]

quite simply....

good.
you knock a submission out nearly everyday
dont you work? lol
anyway keep your stuff coming

AntiClockClock responds:

Right now no, but I will be working next week. :P

[Biohazard 03]

wasnt my cup of tea

some one might like this im not so keen on it i dont like voices that are done that way and i dont think piconjo even played a part in this and your reaping his glory so no marks from me but dont ever give up

Chubaka responds:

Reaping his glory? Piconjo was the one who inspired me to make movies like this, so before you know the facts, shut the fuck up.

[Asylum UK]

dude!

speaking as a guy from bradford well you know how i feel about this

u got a 5 from me

dave-mac-dave responds:

I've just played you strip games! Lots of fun ;). Thanks for the review, good luck with your projects.